chapter of records
Citation check, November 2026
A re-reading of every Safety & Use citation in the Grimoire against its source.
Summary
| Scope | Every citation in the Safety & Use section of all 58 folios: 276 citations to 157 distinct sources |
|---|---|
| Confirmed | 263 citations: the source states what the folio attributes to it |
| Partly confirmed | 2 citations: confirmed as far as the article's abstract goes |
| Not yet checked | 11 citations: the source could not be read automatically (listed below) |
| Errors found | None. No Safety & Use citation was found to misstate its source. |
| Dead links | None found among the sources that could be reached |
How the check was done
Each source was fetched directly from the publisher (U.S. government sites, the European Medicines Agency, university and research libraries, and Europe PMC for journal articles hosted by PubMed Central). For every citation, the figures and key terms in the folio's sentence were searched for in the source text. Citations that did not match automatically were read by hand, including sources in Spanish. A random sample of automatic matches was also read by hand to confirm the method.
Alongside this, the Phase II progress manifest was cross-checked against the folios and the editorial audit: names, numbers, corrected and withheld counts and material status all agree. Four folios (Ginger, Licorice Root, Elderberries and Valerian Root) listed the same NCCIH page twice in their references; the duplicates were merged, so each shows one fewer source than the manifest. Yerba Mate's Safety & Use section was checked again after its Phase II revision, against the revised text.
Partly confirmed
| Folio | Source | What was confirmed |
|---|---|---|
| Moringa | Moringa oleifera: a systematic review of its botany, traditional uses, phytochemistry, pha ↗ | Review covers pharmacology and toxicity across plant parts; dosage-evaluation line beyond the abstract |
| Saffron | Adverse Events of Saffron (Crocus sativus L.): Systematic Review of Cur ↗ | Mostly mild GI events and monitoring at high doses confirmed; anticoagulant and pregnancy cautions need the full text |
Still to check by hand
These sources block automated reading. Each link opens the source; the folio link opens its Safety & Use section.
| Folio | Source | Why it was not read |
|---|---|---|
| Butterfly Pea Flowers | www.efsa.europa.eu ↗ | Behind a bot-security check |
| Lemon Verbena | ABC Herbalgram Website ↗ | Page content loads only in a full browser |
| Lemon Verbena | ABC Herbalgram Website ↗ | Page content loads only in a full browser |
| Lemongrass | Plant vs. Kidney: Evaluating Nephrotoxicity of Botanicals with the Latest Toxicological To ↗ | Full text not openly available; abstract does not cover the claim |
| Licorice Root | www.mdpi.com ↗ | Blocks automated reading |
| Mandarin | Security Verification ↗ | Blocks automated reading |
| Rhodiola Root | www.australian-pharmacognosy.org ↗ | Blocks automated reading |
| Roselle / Hibiscus | ABC Herbalgram Website ↗ | Page content loads only in a full browser |
| Skullcap | ABC Herbalgram Website ↗ | Page content loads only in a full browser |
| Yerba Mate | www.mdpi.com ↗ | Behind a bot-security check |
| Yerba Mate | www.mdpi.com ↗ | Behind a bot-security check |
Not covered by this check
Citations outside Safety & Use (history, folklore, sensory notes and the rest, 1,092 citations) were not read by hand in this pass. Of the 433 whose sources were captured along the way, 410 matched automatically; the other 23 have not been reviewed yet.